
Ask what taxes are for, and you will get a long list: roads, defence, courts, subsidies, consultants, ministerial vehicles. Strip it back to first principles and the answer is shorter. A society pools its money to protect the people in it. That means keeping them alive and well, teaching them, feeding them and giving them somewhere safe to sleep. Everything else is a means to those ends, or a distraction from them.
Seen that way, the argument over social healthcare and education is not really about economics. It is about whether a country believes its people are worth protecting.
Have some humanity
A child who is hungry cannot learn. A parent who cannot afford treatment cannot work, and a family that loses its home loses everything that was holding it together. None of this is exotic. These are the conditions of a decent life, and a state that can guarantee them and chooses not to has made a decision about whose life counts.
The usual defence of that decision is that people should earn their way to healthcare and schooling. But nobody earns being born. A child doesn’t choose her parents’ income, her postcode, or her immune system. Making her access to a doctor or a classroom depend on those accidents turns luck into destiny, and calls it merit.
Nor does a public floor take anything from anyone. Britain has private schools and private hospitals alongside the NHS and state schools. Switzerland, Germany and Australia all combine public guarantees with private options. If you want more than the floor, you can buy it. All the floor does is stop people falling through it, so the only person who loses from its existence is the one who wanted others to fall.
Numbers don’t need a conscience
If compassion isn't enough, the evidence is on the same side. The United States spent 18% of its GDP on health care in 2024, nearly twice the OECD average, yet American life expectancy reached only 79 years, among the shortest in the OECD. The Commonwealth Fund blames the lack of universal coverage and weak primary care, noting that every country in its comparison had a universal system except the U.S. and Mexico. Meanwhile Germany spends 12.3% of GDP and achieves higher life expectancy, while Japan and Switzerland pair modest spending with lifespans of 84 years or more.
The money is not missing. It is being spent badly. Yale researchers project that universal coverage could save about $1 trillion and 114,000 lives every year, after accounting for $304 billion in additional spending to meet unmet needs and provide dental care. That is a preprint and a projection, but it points the same way as every international comparison: the fragmented, for-profit system is the expensive one. Redirecting what is already spent on administration, billing and inflated prices covers more people for less.
The returns on investing in people are just as strong. An international study by the World Inequality Lab and ZEW Mannheim, published in the Journal of Public Economics, estimates that increased spending on education and health pays an average annual productivity return of around ten per cent, with returns for public education sometimes reaching 15 to 20 per cent. A review of education interventions found net benefits to taxpayers of roughly $2 to more than $10 for every dollar invested. Harvard economists studying 133 US policies found that programmes for low-income children’s health and education earned the government an average of $1.78 per dollar spent. A private investment with those returns would be called a bargain.
Education also pays back across the budget. In Ontario, a high-school dropout uses roughly $800 more in public health spending than a graduate, and better graduation rates cut criminal justice costs as well. A healthy, educated population works more, earns more, pays more tax and costs less to look after.
So who objects?
Three groups. The first profits from scarcity: insurers, some private providers, and the lobbyists and politicians who work for them. The second has simply been told that universal care means queues and ruin, which doesn’t match what happens in Germany, Japan or the Netherlands. The third is the largest and the most useful to the other two. These are ordinary people who defend an arrangement that charges them heavily and serves them poorly, and who repeat the arguments of those who profit from it. They do so without pay. There is an old word for that, and it is the one in the headline.
What the critics say
Not every objection comes from that crowd, and some deserve answers.
Waiting times are the strongest one. The Fraser Institute points out that in 2016, 18 per cent of Canadians reported waiting four months or longer for elective surgery, compared with four per cent in the Netherlands, two per cent in France and zero in Germany. But the same body concedes that wait times are not a general characteristic of universal health care countries. The Dutch, French and German systems cover everyone and don’t have Canada’s problem. The lesson is to copy what works, not to abandon universality.
Others worry about cost and about who carries it. Even when total national spending falls, funding comprehensive care requires reallocating public resources, which critics say could mean cuts to other areas. That is a fair concern, and a government that wastes money on the wrong things would waste it here too. It is an argument for competent delivery, not against the principle. Some critics also argue that without competition, providers have less incentive to innovate, and others prefer universal coverage through regulated private insurers. A mixed model is still universal, and the case for a public floor holds in both.
A final objection holds that other public priorities matter too, such as defence, courts, policing, and infrastructure. They do, but each is justified by what it protects, and what it protects is people. A road is valuable because someone needs to travel on it. A court matters because someone needs justice. Health, schooling, food and shelter are what the rest of government exists to serve.
Final thoughts
A government is not a business, and its people are not customers whose worth is measured by what they can afford to buy. Its job is to build a society in which being born poor doesn't condemn someone to being sick, uneducated or homeless. We know this is possible. Other countries have managed it, and the evidence suggests they often do so at a lower cost.
There will always be competing priorities, difficult trade-offs and arguments about how best to deliver public services. But those are arguments about how to protect people, not whether they deserve protecting in the first place.
The question is not whether we can afford to look after one another. It's why we've become so comfortable making excuses for not doing it.
Share this post:


